EU Health Claims Regulation
Back in 2006, the European Union adopted Regulation (EC) No. 1924/2006 (Health Claims) on nutrition and health claims made on foods. A further Health Claims Regulation based on it came into force in December 2012. Here we explain what has changed.
Regulation (EC) No. 1924/2006
As early as 2006, the European Union regulated advertising claims relating to foods through this Regulation to protect health. It specified scientific procedures that had to be used to substantiate health and nutrition claims made on foods.
This meant that claims could no longer be substantiated using just any procedure, but only those approved by the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA). The European Commission retained the final decision-making power.
Claims permitted under the Regulation had already been defined for foods. This laid the foundations for a general ban on advertising claims for foods, with certain exceptions – in legal terms, a prohibition subject to authorisation. As there were many other requirements to consider, this outline serves only as a brief historical overview.
A clear, familiar example of a health claim would be the fibre content of a food and its effect on gut health.
Update through Regulation (EC) No. 432/2012
Over the years, the newly introduced rules were tested for their practical suitability, and the authorities quickly identified a need for improvements. This sowed the seeds for a new regulation, the one mentioned here.
The new Regulation included an appended list of specific statements (health claims), unlike the previous one, which had provided more general guidelines. From then on, only these were permitted and everything else was strictly prohibited. Whereas the previous prohibition subject to authorisation had followed defined guidelines, the same approach now applied with a clearly defined list of health- and disease-related claims. Everything else is now prohibited.
The list is not fixed: it is amended by the EU over time, commented on by individual countries, and there is even a list of so-called “pending health claims” currently under review.
What does this mean for you and for us?
The Health Claims Regulation has advantages and disadvantages for both you and us. It can easily be seen as “overregulation”, but that would be too simplistic. In Germany in particular, where competition law is primarily enforced through formal warning notices between competitors, the 2006 Regulation was not a good solution. Some companies interpreted the Regulation generously, and disputes were repeatedly inevitable. The new Regulation certainly put an end to that. Competition in the market became calmer.
As a customer, you are now also better protected against premature, excessive health- and disease-related claims. You can have considerably more confidence in what you read online than before.
The downside, however, is the very narrow interpretation of health claims. Even commonly known “effects”, for example those of plums, are now prohibited, which caused confusion among the public. There was talk of paternalism. There were also some challenges in the early years in interpreting the claims correctly, although these have now largely been resolved.
In short, since Regulation No. 432/2012 entered into force on 14.12.2012, only the health claims included in that Regulation may be used for products, substances or active ingredients. Health claims not included in this list have no longer been permitted since then. For these reasons, our product descriptions mainly provide information about the quality of the raw materials we use.
What happens next?
As most claims are now completely prohibited for us, satisfying your desire for information is unfortunately entirely up to you. Since we are generally not allowed to help you in this respect, we refer you to the information available online in general. There are also many good online information resources that can help you. Medical databases such as PubMed, as well as other public resources, provide useful guidance on what you may expect from certain substances and active ingredients. For any other questions, we are happy to help as always through our usual contact channels.